How Do You Know When It's Time To Re-brand?

Time To Rebrand

As a creative entrepreneur, when you feel stuck in a rut or bored with your business, what's the FIRST thing you immediately want to do to get excited about your biz again?



I think it’s only natural that we want to update “our look” as our business evolves, just like it’s only natural that we want to evolve our sense of style as we get older.

(As someone who REALLY had a rough time during the low-rise jeans craze in middle and high school, I’m grateful for this fact.)

Yes, ushering your brand into the present is a good thing.

However, there are times when I see entrepreneurs or bloggers or business owners completely overhauling the look of their brand or website every six months to a year, and I think that could be a big mistake.

Here’s why: 

Brands build over time. 

TIME is a crucial part of the magic. Seeing brand elements used consistently over time is when they start to have staying power in the minds of your audience. 

The more time that goes by, the more your audience feels like they know you. They’re comfortable with you. They get you.

If you switch things up too much on them, while it may serve you well in the short-term by giving you a boost in attention to your business, beyond that buzz is just a community that has to get to know you all over again. 

TIME is a crucial part of the magic... The more time that goes by, the more your audience feels like they know you.

So, all that said, here are my quick rules for knowing WHEN a brand or website re-design is a good move.

(And keep in mind, I’m talking about a pretty major overhaul, not just adding a new section to your blog sidebar or switching out your body font.) 

1. Update your website if the primary objective of your website has changed.

If you don't have a primary objective for your website... you should!

It helps to know what you're trying to accomplish because that will inform the layout and design for your site. 

For example, about eight months in to Made Vibrant, I wanted to get serious about taking on more client work, and so the primary objective for my site was to create more inbound design leads. That's it.

I made that the focus on the home page and called out my services throughout various parts of the site, not to mention the fact that I consolidated my three separate Wordpress sites into one Squarespace site so that all of my blog traffic would flow directly to my design services. 

Eight months after that, my primary objective changed again. Made Vibrant evolved from a client service business into a products & resources business.

That's a pretty big shift in both audience and message, so I had to update my site to reflect that new objective.

But, two website re-designs in less than two years can feel like a lot for the exact reasons I mentioned above. That's why I deliberately left parts of my brand in tact during those transitions. 

The logo, the keystone pattern, and the overall vibrant tone of the brand remained consistent, keeping things familiar and comfortable. That helped usher my community through the process of those various website re-designs/brand updates.

2. Update your brand if you feel it no longer accurately reflects the personality of you or your business.  

I am not just an advocate for unique branding; I'm an advocate for authentic branding.

I believe your website and brand is your opportunity to communicate who you are and what you're about to your audience. It's your chance to attract the right kind of people, people that see you and your business for who they really are. That's why it's so important that the design reflects your true sense of self. 

Let's say you're a photographer who has been shooting weddings for the past five years and your brand has been all romance and fairytales, but now you feel like maybe if you look at another dang piece of white cake you might just SCREAM... well then, yeah, in that case it's time to move on from romance and fairytales. That's not your vibe anymore, it isn't coming from a sincere place, and so that's your cue that it's the right time for an update.

3. Update your brand/site if you feel your current look and feel is affecting your confidence.

The first two reasons have more to do with how branding can help you when it comes to other people (your audience/community, etc.)

But what I don’t think gets talked about nearly enough is the other, less obvious reason for having a quality brand: that it makes you feel good. 

Now, I don’t mean to make it overly simple. It’s just that in business, confidence is so important.

Being able to tell someone what you do, what you believe in, and who you want to help with conviction is the key to getting someone on board with your mission. And if you don’t have a brand or a website that you’re proud of, you may not feel so compelled to share your business with the world. 

If you feel like your current website or brand is preventing you from projecting confidence in your mission or business, then by all means throw every other rule out the window and invest the time to change it. 

BONUS RULE: Being bored with your branding is not a good enough reason to change it. 

If you're changing your branding or website, either you're a) a designer, in which case you're investing a lot of time and energy or b) you're hiring someone, in which case you're investing time, energy AND money.

You owe it to yourself and your business to make sure those investments are worth it.

Feel like your vibe doesn't suit your tastes or reflect your true self anymore? By all means, change something.

Want to update your typography or add some fun graphic elements that reflect a new skill (eh hem, hand-lettering…), okay awesome! Go right ahead!

BUT, please, please do not just overhaul the thing because you’re bored. 

Spend that time and energy on reaching your business goals and give your brand the time it needs to start working for you.

Your Challenge

Think about which of the above three rules applies to you and your creative business. 

Is it time to rethink the objective of your website or update your brand? Do you feel confident in your branding and what it's communicating to your audience? 

Do a little audit and ask yourself why you do or don't feel the need to give things a facelift right now.

And, of course, if you ARE feeling justified in the need for a brand refresh and need a resource to walk you through it, consider joining us in the course.

Here's your TL,DR quick reference guide.

Pin it for easy reference in the future!

How do you know when it's time to rebrand?

Free 7-day Branding Email Course

Figure out who you want to reach and what you want to say in less than 7days. Brand clarity awaits!

3 Factors That Separate Good Branding From Great Branding

3 Factors The Separate Good Branding From Great Branding

We all know that branding is a vital part of building a successful online business.

Cohesive, modern branding helps lend credibility and professionalism to your online presence, which is key when you’re trying to get your name out there and start cultivating a community.

But, when does branding go beyond simply lending legitimacy to your business? What elements of branding actually have the power to move the needle when it comes to expanding your audience, or - even better - your revenue?

In my experience, I’ve found that three different factors lead to varying levels of effectiveness in brand design.

They are attentionunderstanding and resonance.

But, the major catch here is that all three of these are NOT created equal. Each one conveys a different level of connection between your company and someone who comes across your brand, contributing to whether that person becomes a paying customer/client. (And we can all agree paying customers/clients is a very good thing, right? Right.)

Let’s dive into each factor, but first I want to paint a little picture for you.

Imagine you’re strolling through Times Square on a busy day. Every 20 feet or so you run into a different street performer, each one vying for your attention. Some are aggressive, some are boring, some are intriguing and others are just flat out entertaining.

The truth is, though, they all have the same goal in mind: to get you to stop walking, hang out for a while, and eventually to drop some cash into their hats.

Hmmm… stop, hang out for a while, and offer up some money. Sound familiar?

Yep, that’s online business in a nutshell, my friends.

Think about it. That’s all any of us is trying to do: go out there, put on our best show, and try to capture the hearts of people browsing the web so we can create a profitable business.

Now, as any good street performer knows, if you’re going to get someone to give you a few bucks, you’re first going to need them to stop walking and pay attention.

Which brings me to our first factor:


1. Attention

If branding was a video game, Attention would be Level One. (Yep, for those of you keeping track at home, that’s street performers and video games. What can I say? I’m trying to keep it interesting for ya!)

It’s no secret that, as a culture, our attention spans are as fleeting as ever, and if you have any hope of building an audience, you first have to get on their radar. The mission of Level One is to use your brand to simply stand out in the sea of your competitors.

I love how Seth Godin defines the term “brand” on his blog:

“A brand is the set of expectations, memories, stories and relationships that, taken together, account for a consumer’s decision to choose one product or service over another.”

Inherently in his definition, Seth implies that the whole point of developing a brand is to rise above your peers. (Peers are more commonly referred to as "competitors" but I hate the idea of reinforcing that comparison mindset, so let's instead say "differentiate yourself within the peer landscape.") But to do that, you first have to be seen.

This means doing research. Take a look at the various businesses in your industry. In what ways are they zigging that you could be zagging?

Be careful, though. Make sure that whatever branding you develop comes from an authentic place, not just an interest in standing out from the pack. Don’t drench your site in neon colors just because you don’t see anyone else in your category doing it. If you do that and you’re a watercolor artist that sells pastel florals, your brand is going to feel dissonant with your business foundation. On the other hand, if you’re a fun and energetic resource shop for creatives with vibrant in your brand name, it just might work. 😉

When my friends, Omar and Nicole started their business, The $100 MBA, they did so with the belief that they could challenge the norm when it comes to business education. The advice they give is practical and energetic. That mix of rebelliousness (challenging the norm) and energy/enthusiasm brings an underlying authenticity to their red, black and white brand color palette.

Here are some questions to ask yourself if you’re trying to achieve attention:

  • Does my branding stand out in a lineup of similar businesses in my category or niche?
  • Would I stick around if I stumbled across a site like mine?

Now, The only problem with striving for a brand that only aims to garner attention is that it’s fleeting. A flashy street performer might be able to make you stop for five minutes to watch, but unless there’s something to keep you there, then you’ll eventually just move on, right? If you’re only attempting to gain attention, it’s likely that whatever traffic you do manage to get will come and go.

Which brings me to the next level of branding achievement - understanding.


2. Understanding

Once you have the attention of someone, if you want any hope of keeping them engaged for the long haul, you’re going to have to effectively communicate what you do. Great branding should be designed to reinforce and support your company’s message. You can use elements in your brand identity to give contextual clues to your audience, letting them quickly decipher what your business is and if it might be for them.

Take Evernote, for example. I love the elephant icon in their logo because it reinforces the original purpose of their product, which is to help you keep track of and remember things. Though someone might not make the connection right away, if they see the logo in context, the elephant image is a memorable icon that supports the understanding of their product.

Image source

Branding not only has the power to enhance understanding of a product, it can also lead to a deeper understanding of a company’s differentiator (which is especially useful for a service-based company.)

Take the design studio, Ghostly Ferns, for example, a creative studio that declares on its website that it’s “Not your average design studio” and they only work with “happy companies.”

Aside from the large and direct brand statements, as a visitor to the website, I immediately notice that the branding is unexpected and whimsical. Not only have they grabbed my attention with a distinct, inspired brand, but now I understand that their aesthetic and differentiator is the unconventional nature of their designs and the value they place on friendly client relationships. The branding reinforces the communication, and if I leave the site, I walk away with a deeper insight into what their business is about.

Some questions to ask yourself if you’re trying to achieve understanding:

  • Does my brand have a tone or energy that is aligned with the basic facets of my business (who I’m trying to target, what my focus is, what I believe in?)
  • Does my brand identity offer any clues as to what my business is about or who it’s for?

Attention and understanding can be powerful, but I would argue that, most of the time, neither one is enough to ensure that a passerby converts into a customer --or better yet -- a fan.

So, then, what turns a person from a casual visitor into a customer, a client, or a brand advocate? What makes the person in Times Square throw their fiver into a street performer’s hat, or -- what’s even more powerful -- go tell their friends about the experience they had with that one special performer?

The answer is resonance.


3. Resonance

You did it! You’ve made it to the final level of effective branding and if you can tackle the Boss - Brand Resonance - then you win the ultimate game reward: a brand advocate.

Resonance is all about going a step beyond speaking to someone’s mind and instead, speaking straight to their heart and their soul.

As Simon Sinek poignantly said in his TEDx talkStart With Why“People don’t buy what you do, they buy WHY you do it.”

After working with dozens of branding clients - from solopreneurs to large marketing companies - one thing has become clear to me: crafting a powerful brand story is the first step in connecting with your brand’s true fans.

Just to be clear, when I say “brand story,” I’m referring to the unique narrative that conveys the heart and soul of your business. I like to think of brand story as the melting pot of answers to all those important, juicy, deeply-rooted questions about your business and what it stands for.

Questions like:

  • What does your business believe in?
  • Why did you get started?
  • Who are you passionate about serving and why?
  • Why do you get up every morning excited about your business?

Every place and way that you communicate that narrative - whether it’s through your brand identity (your logo, color palette, photography, typography, etc.), your copy, or an event experience - is an opportunity to make an emotional connection with a potential customer or client.

Brand resonance happens when the values and beliefs of a brand align with the values and beliefs of an individual. 

But, in order for brand resonance to occur, you have to invest the time in understanding what your beliefs and values are as a business. You have to know what you stand for and bake that into your brand. That’s what will give you the power to create lasting members of your tribe.

For example, this business, Made Vibrant, is based on the belief that when we show up as our truest, most vibrant selves, the world is a better place. It’s an imperfect process, but it’s about the growth we all experience along the way. This underlying belief is reflected in the bright and vibrant colors of my brand, and the emphasis on the imperfect process comes through in the hand-drawn elements seen throughout my branding. Those visuals, coupled with the direct, mission-driven copy, were intentionally created to resonate with creatives that are motivated to grow.

I can’t tell you how many emails I’ve received with sentences like:

“It’s like you were talking right to me!”
“I found Made Vibrant at the perfect time!”
“This is exactly what I needed.”

That is the exact kind of response you’re aiming for.

Resonance gets you an engaged audience and an engaged audience gets you clients, sales and revenue. Not only will people stick around to hear what you have to say, they’re going to buy, and - even better - they’re going to tell their friends to check you out too.


So, let’s recap:

There’s attention. (“Ohh, look at that.”)
There’s understanding. (“Ohh, I see what that company does.”)
Then there’s resonance. (“Ohhh, that company GETS me.”)

Remember, branding isn’t JUST about your logo or the fonts you choose for your website. It’s the sum of every tangible and intangible connection someone has with your business.

Most branding - even good branding - stops at levels one or two of this list. Good branding is well-designed, professional, attention-grabbing and aids in the communication of what a company does.

But excellent branding? Excellent branding transcends attention and understanding and hits you right in the heart.

I encourage you to take a look at your own branding and see where you stack up against each of these three levels. 

If you’re dressed as a break-dancing grandma in Times Square, sure, I’ll probably stop for five minutes to watch you dance.

BUT, if you’re dressed as a break-dancing grandma in Times Square with a big photo of your own grandma beside you, wearing her track suit because she loved to dance and back in her heyday she taught you everything you know about break-dancing... well then HECK YEAH I’m going to give you my money. And HECK YEAH I’m going to remember you AND tell my friends about you because I love my grandma and she taught me things too.

Resonance, my friends. That is when your branding will truly start to move the needle.


Free 7-day Branding Email Course

Figure out who you want to reach and what you want to say in less than 7days. Brand clarity awaits!